Without criticism, you also have no distance from the text by which you give life to yourself as a thinker. Agreeing with an author against a fellow student: Stating Your Thesis A thesis is a one- sentence statement about your topic.
Why does it matter whether an author is persuasive in her analysis? There are many time-honored strategies for critical writing. Notice, though, that a sentence stating an obvious and indisputable truth won't work as a thesis: In many cases, you are teaching your audience something new about the text.
You should discuss the area into which your topic fits, and then gradually lead into your specific field of discussion re: All these matters of context can contribute to your assessment of what is going on in a text. Do you agree with the author or disagree?
I'm sure that all of you have heard someone assert views with which you strongly concur or which you strongly oppose. Rather, you may ask of yourself only that you stay one step ahead of your reader. If you can maintain a critical train of thought from one week to the next, by summoning in your mind an agenda of your own making through which you will read the texts, you may be able to get a greater depth in your criticism.
Why should we agree or disagree?
Before you can come up with an argument on any topic, you have to collect and organize evidence, look for possible relationships between known facts such as surprising contrasts or similaritiesand think about the beneath-the-surface significance of these relationships.
What do you want your reader to look at again? What are some weaknesses in her writing? The essence of criticism consists not of disagreement with the text, but of distance from the text. Please keep in mind that direct quotes must support your argument and not compensate for it. Her conclusion is that we need to personally decide not to use a cell phone while driving and that we need to educate our friends and family to give up cell phones while driving, too.
Then, follow up with a further rebuttal of your own "But, notwithstanding the author's response, I continue to assert that This means that you should not substitute the quotation for your own articulation of a point.
This can be done only after a close and careful reading of the text. Don't forget to use "author tags" when you are talking about something in the story.
What is persuasive and compelling? Are the conclusions warranted by the evidence presented? The following steps are how this is done. You can write a critical essay that agrees entirely with the reading.
Each section should logically follow and lead into the sections that come before it and after it. Diction Diction refers to the choice of words for the expression of ideas; the construction, disposition, and application of words in your essay, with regard to clearness, accuracy, variety, etc. Paragraphs Creating clear paragraphs is essential.
Within each paragraph, sentences should be logically connected to one another. You can disagree with the article and explain three or more reasons why. When highlighting a text or taking notes from it, teach yourself to highlight argument: Rather, you may ask of yourself only that you stay one step ahead of your reader.A Reading Abstract is a critical summary of the assigned text(s).
It is a mini-essay ( words) that combines three elements: summary, analysis and critique. The goal of a Reading Abstract is to effectively summarize the central argument of a given text while at the same time express your own critical response to it (i.
e., your position). The word "critical" has positive as well as negative meanings. You can write a critical essay that agrees entirely with the reading. The word "critical" describes your attitude when you read the article. Critically Reading a Position Essay Due: Saturday Points: 20 To test the thesis that argument can be found everywhere, read “The Argument Culture” starting on page () .
In an MS Word document, copy and paste an example of an argument and explain why it can be defined as such. Critically Reading a Position Essay Due: Saturday Points: 20 To test the thesis that argument can be found everywhere, read “The Argument Culture” starting on page () .
In an MS Word document, copy and paste an example of an argument and explain why it can be defined as such. After studying critical thinking for a semester, with the knowledge that I have gained in the class and self-reading, therefore I do have the confidence that I deserve to get B in critical thinking subject due to the support point that provided in this essay and also with the 3/5(2).
The body of the position paper may contain several paragraphs. Each paragraph should present an idea or main Each paragraph should present an idea or main concept that iesclarif a portion of the position statement and is supported by evidence or facts.Download